Consumer Report Best Mascara – Reviews Of Top Rated Picks

Last updated:

Mascara is one of the makeup essentials that is used by women almost every day before getting out either for work, hang out with friends or, for a date. It is the most important part of eye makeup and works on giving beautiful lashes with a dramatic look. A quality mascara should be reliable if nothing else.

Not all mascaras do what they are advertised as. Some will give you smudgy raccoon eyes while others may have you end up having dramatic mascara tears. It is all in the formula. You need a mascara formula that can withstand ugly crying, elements, weather, allergy season, and everything in between.   

You need not worry; we have got you covered! We have designed this post to help all the women out there to choose the right product for their eyelashes based on our consumer report best mascara review.

Let's jump right into it.

Reviews Of 10 Best Mascaras Consumer Report

1. Maybelline New York Total Temptation – Amazon's Choice 

consumer report best mascara reviews

Maybelline New York Total Temptation is the most popular mascara on our list. Trusted by hundreds and thousands of beauty experts and professionals alike, the Total Temptation goes on smoothly, dries fast, and stays put throughout the day, no matter what the season or weather is.

It is a preferred choice for perfectly separated eyelashes that don't clump, smudge, or flake. This mascara incorporates a whipped and creamy formula that is specially infused with coconut extract to give you dreaming eyelashes. The best part is that the Total Temptation mascara is available in three different shades – brownish-black, very black, and blackest black.

You can easily remove the mascara after the day ends. However, for best results, the company suggests using Maybelline Expert Eyes makeup remover. But you can use another product as well.

2. COVERGIRL Lash Blast Volume Mascara – Best Overall 

consumer report best mascara reviews

COVERGIRL Lash Blast Volume Mascara gives you the freedom to redefine makeup. With this mascara, you can create a look that you feel is the most beautiful yet comfortable. It incorporates volume-boosting formula that max out every lash and enhances the volume for your desired look.

It is clump-free and easy to apply. Lash Blast mascara comes in four different color shades – very black, brown, black-brown, and black – that gives you an instant blast of fullness and length. Therefore, you can choose how bold and classy you want to go.

This mascara is excellent for smooth application, lengthening, volumizing, and separating lashes. The best part is that this product from COVERGIRL is Cruelty-Free International certified, meaning it is not tested on animals.  

3. Maybelline Full 'N Soft - Best For Length

consumer report best mascara reviews

For those who complain about not getting the desired length with their lashes, Maybelline Full 'N Soft is the answer to that. It is the consumer reports best mascara for length that has an advanced thickening formula to create fuller and softer looking lashes. It is filled with vitamin E that nourishes the lashes, preventing lash loss.

It can be easily removed, making it suitable for users who wear contact lenses. You can amp up your look, keep it classic, or go for natural, smooth, and clump-free look with Maybelline Full 'N Soft - it has what you need to create any look from natural to dramatic.

This mascara is available in two color shades – washable very black and waterproof very black. You can choose the one that suits your makeup requirements and needs.

4. L'Oreal Paris Lash Paradise Mascara - Best For Volume

consumer report best mascara reviews

If you have thin eyelashes and have tried all the products out there and still getting no results, then you must try L'Oreal Paris Lash Paradise Mascara. This is the first-ever voluptuous volume-enhancing mascara. It delivers a full lash fringe that is feathery soft with no clumping, smudging, and flaking.

It delivers full and long eyelashes thanks to the 200+ bristle mascara brush. The smooth glide formula ensures that every lash is coated, delivering silky volume and quality finish with a single coat.   

Its brush design and mascara formula will help you create a look that you desire. From party to casual, formal office meetings, and more, there isn't any look that you cannot create with L'Oreal Paris Lash Paradise Mascara.

5. Tetyana Naturals 4D Silk Fiber Lash Mascara – Best Smudge-proof 

consumer report best mascara reviews

Tetyana Naturals Lash Mascara is the ultimate eye makeup that you have always desired. This smudge-proof 4D Silk Fiber Lash Mascara incorporates gentle yet powerful mascara formula that delivers length, lift, volume, and definition for the ultimate gorgeous look. With a single stroke, you will see a complete transformation of your lashes.

This deep and rich mascara is perfect for light, thin, and short lashes, glamorously coating your lashes flawlessly so that you don't have to spend time and money on fake eyelashes. Its feature points include longer, thicker, voluminous lashes; hypoallergenic formula; easy application and removal; smudge and flake-free; waterproof; lasts all day, and intensely pigmented.

All you have to do is apply the mascara in the morning, and you don't have to worry about your look for the rest of the day.

6. Endlessly Beautiful All-natural and Organic Mascara – Best Organic 

consumer report best mascara reviews

While it is the most expensive mascara on our list, it is the best organic you can get. The All-natural and Organic Mascara from Endlessly Beautiful makes lashes look fuller and longer without smudges, flakes, or clumps. This is an excellent formula for lengthening and thickening your eyelashes. Those who refrain from using mascara because they have sensitive eyes, you no more have to stop yourself from exploring your true beauty.

This mascara is made using non-toxic and chemical-free ingredients that are best for sensitive eyes and those who wear contact lenses. The best part is that the nourishing formula promotes eyelash growth. It is paraben and gluten-free, gentle and moisturizing, and 100% cruelty-free.

The mascara will last the whole day without getting with sweat and water, and it is easy to remove as well.

7. Vivienne Sabó Classic French Mascara Cabaret Premiere – Best Premium 

consumer report best mascara reviews

If you are looking for a cost-effective beauty solution without compromising on the quality, then Vivienne Sabó Classic French Mascara Cabaret Premiere will give you that dramatic French look that everybody wants. This classic mascara is perfect for everyday use and will provide you with voluminous and defined lashes with just a single coat. Thanks to its miniature bristles, even the fanned and thicker lashes will get an optimal look.

The formula is lightweight, meaning it won't exert any pressure on your eyelashes preventing it from breaking. The clump-free mascara gives you a soft, smudge-free, natural, and long-lasting look.  

The petite wand makes it easy for you to apply mascara and the small bristles make sure that the mascara is spread evenly all over the lashes.

8. Maybelline New York Sensational – Best Washable 

consumer report best mascara reviews

The next in our list is another mascara from Maybelline New York, which is popular for its washable feature. Maybelline New York Sensational incorporates a formula that makes it easy for the users to clean the mascara from the eyelashes post use.

But don't get the idea that if it is easily washable what good it can be. The mascara comes with the exclusive fanning brush with ten layers of bristles that spreads the eyelashes equally and gives it a full-fan effect.

The Maybelline New York Sensational will provide you with a smooth, natural, and clump-free look.  

9. Gracefulvar 4D Silk Fiber Eye Lash Mascara – Best Budget 

consumer report best mascara reviews

Gracefulvar is one of the few beauty brands that offer budget-friendly beauty products. Its 4D Silk Fiber Eye Lash Mascara is one of the best in the market that is deeply pigmented and instantly creates beautifully bold and dramatic lashes with just a single coat.

The manufacturer has used a safe and innovative mascara formula that is made non-toxic and natural ingredients. This ensures that the mascara will not cause any kind of irritation or allergy post-application. Moreover, this is a great option for those who wear contact lenses.

The mascara formula is long-lasting and waterproof; however, it requires patience and skills to apply the mascara on the lashes correctly.  

10. COVERGIRL Professional All-in-One Straight Brush Mascara – Best Multipurpose 

consumer report best mascara reviews

If you are looking for a mascara for daily usage that offers clump-free application, then you can consider getting Professional All-in-One Straight Brush Mascara from COVERGIRL.

This 3-in-1 all-day mascara lets you define and darken your eyelashes like a professional beautician. You will get the definition, length, and volume without smudging or smearing, all thanks to the curved brush that equally spreads the mascara to each and every single eyelash, even those didn't know you had.

This 3-in-1 is perfect for tending not only your eyelashes but works great for eyebrows, eyeliner, and eye shadow as well.   

Conclusion 

That's it! We have reviewed the consumer report best mascara based on their features and best use case. We hope that you find it informative. As you can see that there are different varieties and brands of mascara available, so you need to choose one based on your requirements and the mascara features. The ones we have mentioned are of excellent quality, providing thick and lasting look throughout the day. Whenever you are shopping for mascara, you need to emphasize on significant features like clump-free, washable, waterproof, etc. This will ensure that you get the right product that's worth its value.

Top Posts